![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| An Article by Warren Beauchamp | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Q&A Making it Wide Making it Narrow Examples Crank Length Conclusions | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Questions and Answers
Q: What is
this Q-factor thing? Q: How do you figure out what your Q-factor is? Q: Why do I care about Q-factor? Making it Wide Making it Narrow When thinking about using a narrower crank, think about how many chain rings you will need. If you will need a triple chain ring, you probably want to stick with an MTB crank, if you only need two, you can use a road crank, and if you only need one chain ring you can use custom narrow crank, a specialized BMX crank set like the Odyssey Black Widow Euro (See Black Widow Lites cranks on DansComp.com) or an obsolete French crank set like the B.S.A. Nervar. If you still need to get narrower, you can use a custom BB. Phil Wood makes a 96mm BB as a stock item, which requires a narrowed BB shell, and a special Phil tool to install it. If you still need a narrower Q-factor, you can hack a couple inches out of a perfectly good 107mm BB spindle and weld it back together, making it about 53mm. The Coslinger team used this technique on their Coslinger streamliner. Thom Ollinger says he cut about 2 inches out of the spindle. To make it work he used a hollow BB spindle, cut it, and pinned it together. He made a fixture to hold it straight and with the crank flats lined up, and then TIG welded it. He then built up the bearing areas with weld and turned them on a lathe, leaving about .020 on the diameter. After that he put the part between centers and ground the diameters to match the inside diameter of the bearings. There is only .060 between the two bearings. This allowed them to have a Q width, plus shoes width of 12 inches. While a BB narrowed in this manner is perfectly good for racing, the bearings are so close together that there will probably be a little play and reduced bearing life. Also available is a custom manufactured 61mm BB spindle and bearings from Phil Wood. Thom had Phil Wood make up a small run of these beauties. This custom Phil Wood BB spindle and bearings require a custom BB, but allow us to have a 4.1 inch Q factor with the Shimano cranks, for a total pedal box width of 13.1 inches.
Crank
Length Mechanical means can also be used to reduce the pedal box size. The Kingsbury team uses a complicated crank system called the K-drive to obtain an elliptical pedal path. This is probably as close as you can come to a linear drive system without all the power loss associated with linear drive systems. To make pedal box measurements you can get someone to watch you pedal on a trainer and do some measurements. Sean Costin made a video of himself to observe how he pedaled, which was how they optimized the Coslinger fairing to his exact pedal stroke. Alternatively you can just hang your shoes on your pedals, and start measuring. The top of the stroke is pretty easy. Almost everyone's stroke is with the toe straight up from the pedal at the top of the stroke. The bottom of the stroke varies more by BB height and personal pedaling style. If you pull on the pedals more, your foot doesn't hang down as far. Even though you can make your foot hang straight down at the bottom of the stroke, this never actually happens while you pedal, so make sure you measure this well, and you can potentially save a lot of pedal box height. Summing it up |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||